Léim ar aghaidh chuig an bpríomhábhar
Gnáthamharc

Dáil Éireann díospóireacht -
Tuesday, 9 Jun 2026

Vol. 1087 No. 1

Saincheisteanna Tráthúla - Topical Issue Debate

Health Services

Is mór agam an deis seo a thapú labhairt ar cheist atá tar éis teacht faoi mo bhráid le cúpla mí anuas. Baineann sé le cúrsaí súile. Issues and concerns that have been raised with me by constituents about our eye care model in Ireland. We know, for example, that public eye care services are under significant pressure. National Treatment Purchase Fund, NTPF, data shows that over 42,000 people are waiting for eye care appointments, with approximately 33% of those waiting longer than one year.

While much attention is rightly focused on that side of the thing, what I want to talk about today relates to our community eye care model and whether it is equipped to identify and manage emerging eye health challenges, particularly among children and young people. The current paediatric eye care pathway is focused on early childhood screening and the identification of serious visual impairments, but I do not think this captures the changing nature of eye health among children and adolescents, particularly when we take account of the rapid rise in the incidents of myopia, or short-sightedness.

We know myopia typically develops between the ages of eight and 16, after school entry vision screening has taken place. This raises the question as to whether some children are developing vision problems without any structured follow-up or monitoring and, in fact, in many cases a diagnosis is reactive because a child will complain, for example, that they cannot see the blackboard or cannot engage properly with a lesson. By that stage, there would have been some lag in academic outcomes and the vision problem would have presented itself.

Emerging evidence from Ireland and abroad would suggest that myopia is becoming increasingly common, particularly in younger age groups, with clinic based data showing the highest rate of myopia now among people in their 20s. While long-sightedness remains more prevalent in clinical populations, adjusted population estimates indicate that myopia is now becoming more prevalent as an eye condition, which shows the changing nature of eye health.

We know that undetected vision problems can negatively affect educational attainment, classroom participation, confidence and social development. Also, myopia is associated with a lifelong increase in serious eye disease like retinal detachment, glaucoma or cataracts. This risk of myopia and the severity of it increases with age and we know that high myopia is much more associated with a high risk of vision loss compared with normal vision. This has significant public health implications. Individuals with high myopia face the greatest risk. The overall burden on services is likely driven by the growing number of people with moderate myopia as well. We estimate that 50% of the global population could be myopic by 2050.

This is something we need to be very aware of in terms of how we design our eye care model and whether we should have proactive monitoring in place. One immediate action we could take is to encourage and enable independent prescription of medicines for eye conditions by optometrists in Ireland, which is something that is not in place at the moment. International evidence would suggest that allowing those prescribing powers to be made available to optometrists can allow more patients to be treated safely in the community. This reduces unnecessary hospital referrals and eases pressures on ophthalmology services. Large-scale clinical data from a number of studies suggests that electronic medical records can enable this as a potential cost effective tool for monitoring trends in eye health.

Will the Minister of State give us a view on the current model of the eye care pathway, especially at a paediatric level? Given our educational system is becoming more reliant on screens and we know there is greater use of screens, that in itself is compounding the issues affecting myopia and increasing its prevalence, as evidenced by the data. Ultimately, can we build an early warning or early detection system into our paediatric eye care pathway?

I thank Deputy Moynihan for raising this really important issue of eye care services in line with emerging trends. I am taking this on behalf of the Minister for Health, Deputy Carroll MacNeill.

There are measures either in place or being progressed to address the emerging trends in eye care services, such as those due to an ageing demographic or an increase in the prevalence of myopia. The Health Service Executive provides optical services free of charge to children referred from child health and school health service examinations who are discovered to have sight problems. These children are referred to the appropriate service for treatment. Under the community ophthalmic services scheme, COSS, medical card holders and their dependants aged over 12 can be seen by ophthalmologists, optometrists or dispensing opticians. They can receive an eye examination and be provided with prescribed optical appliances in accordance with a national schedule of approved optical appliances.

In 2017, the HSE published two important documents, the Primary Care Eye Services Review Group Report and the national clinical programme for ophthalmology. The review report set out how a significant proportion of eye services could be delivered in a primary care setting. A key recommendation was that children aged between eight and 12 with routine eye care needs should be transferred to the care of local optometrists. These would receive an annual eye exam under the COSS, irrespective of their medical card eligibility. This remains a priority and work is ongoing to implement this recommendation.

The clinical programme set out a model of care regarding how the realignment of eye services from an acute hospital setting to the community would be undertaken. The HSE has been developing multidisciplinary integrated eye care teams in accordance with this model of care. These teams facilitate assessment, diagnoses, management and treatment, enabling most patients to be seen in their own locality. Where necessary, patients can be referred onwards to acute ophthalmology services to receive the necessary specialist input.

Significant investment has been made in developing and strengthening these integrated eye care teams. There are ten across the six health regions. These teams are also facilitating the large-scale transfer of care from hospital outpatient departments to community settings, with a substantial proportion of referrals assessed, treated and discharged outside the acute system. This has reduced pressure on hospital ophthalmology clinics, enabling acute services to prioritise complex, surgical and high-risk patients, and has improved patient experience through earlier assessment, shorter waiting times and care delivered closer to home.

Work is also under way to ensure Ireland has enough trained eye care professionals to deal with increasing demand: The South East Technological University, SETU, is progressing work to establish a bachelor of science honours degree in optometry, with a first intake of students expected in September 2027. I have been working closely with Professor John Nolan and Dr. Fraser Horn, who have done phenomenal work in the last couple of years to embed this into the new technological university.

They were very supportive of this "one health" approach. You have to have the eye care professionals in place to deliver an awful lot of the services.

I am really struck by what the Deputy said as well about optometrists being able to take that step in regard to dealing with children especially. We have seen how the Minister and the previous Minister have moved in relation to pharmacists now being able to prescribe up to 12 different medications, which is really important.

The Department of Enterprise, Tourism and Employment also recently announced that the ophthalmic optician is now an eligible occupation for the critical skills employment permit. Finally, the Department is also considering ways to expend the scope of practice for optometrists to ensure that the eye care needs of people, especially children and older persons, can be met.

I thank the Minister of State for that very comprehensive response. Core to a lot of the emerging healthcare needs we have in Ireland are training and skills, so I am very pleased to see that one of the planks of the Minister of State's answer was making sure we have enough trained professionals. I think that needs to be at the core of how we future-proof our public services and make sure we are able to address demand in the future. I also welcome the steps that are being taken towards embedding this into a community care model, which I think is what these integrated eye care teams will deliver. They are contingent on the number of trained professionals.

I ask the Minister of State to take it up with the Minister for Health in a broader piece around the prescribing powers for optometrists to enable them to be a core pillar of how we engage directly with children in the community and to avoid them necessarily having to even go as far as the integrated eye care team, especially if medication or treatment can be prescribed in a low-cost setting.

While all the other developments the Minister of State described are very welcome, there is a piece around early detection. Even with the model that is laid out at the moment, it seems to be a referral or reactive, which is a very good and strong way to find this. Given that we know this is going to have increased protection, studies from the US and South Korea suggest that myopia affects 50% of the population towards the middle of their lives, and that that, as the Minister of State knows, brings added risk of eye disease later on in life, how do we build on that early detection piece, in the same way we would have done with dental care and on the back of public health nurse checks in the first years of a baby's life? How do we keep an eye on - pardon the pun - the development of eye health and eye care but also address and ensure we use the data to inform monitoring and planning and learn about the prevalence of myopia? One thing the increased use of screens has taught us is that nobody would have anticipated that it has had a very detrimental effect on the overall state of the eye health of children and adults in the country, which has led to this increased prevalence of myopia. I thank the Minister of State for the response, and she might respond to the other points too.

It is great to have the opportunity to discuss the reform of eye care services in line with emerging trends across the country. Deputy Michael Murphy, who is sitting in front of Deputy Moynihan, has discussed with me several times the issue of getting the right clinicians into the job. We have been really challenged, for example, in south Tipperary in getting a consultant optometrist in there to fill that post. That is why it is really important we have the training skills across the country. We do not have enough positions at the moment. I am strongly of that opinion and we are trying to change that. That is really important.

The Deputy talked about eye care. Often when we think of eyes, we think about the glasses or the contact lenses but eye care is very important. There is a huge amount of work done with older people with dementia, macular degeneration and cataracts. It is very important that the quality of life of a person can be so much improved if they have the correct eye care.

Myopia - short-sightedness or nearsightedness - is increasing among children both globally and in Ireland. Research indicates that daily outdoor activities and managing children's screen time and sleep time may be beneficial for slowing the progress of myopia. Children discovered to have sight problems, including myopia, during HSE screenings get free treatment from their local HSE integrated eye care team, but I am conscious of waiting lists and where a young child is waiting. I am conscious again of the situation in south Tipperary, which has been raised. We failed over the past two years to get a consultant in post, and that ends up creating very long waiting lists for children. As we all know, regardless of what health issue it is, early intervention is key.

I will raise with the Minister again the prescribing element of it, because the more services we can move away from the acute hospital setting and into the community, the better. I thank the Deputy again for raising this.

Health Services

I raise the ongoing closure of the south Tipperary memory clinic in Cashel and the growing impact it is having on patients and families across the county. I thank the Minister of State for taking the question, as I know it is an area she is very familiar with, given her previous responsibility in this area.

Through a number of parliamentary questions I submitted recently, I received confirmation from the HSE that the memory clinic has been closed since January 2026. There is no reopening date, and while there is a review under way, families have no certainty as to when a fully functioning service will be restored. The figures provided to me by the HSE are deeply concerning. There are currently 450 patients awaiting an initial assessment and a further 168 waiting for follow-up appointments. That is a total of 618 people caught up in a system that is simply not functioning.

This matters, as the Minister of State well knows, because dementia diagnosis is not a luxury; it is a gateway to treatment, care planning, family support and future decision-making. While the HSE points to dementia advisers and other support services, those services are not a substitute for diagnosis itself. What families want and what patients deserve is timely assessment and diagnosis.

I know the Minister of State is very familiar with the dementia model of care. I think that sets out a pathway for timely access to assessment and intervention of six weeks, yet in south Tipperary, we have a situation where public memory clinics have ceased operating entirely. Patients are being left indefinitely, while GPs are being provided with information on private providers. I think that raises serious questions about equity of access.

Will the Minister of State address the stark contrast with services available in other parts of the south east? I know the tremendous work the Minister of State has done in Waterford and Wexford, both of which provide a structured multidisciplinary approach to dementia assessment and support. Why is a comparable service not available to the people of south Tipperary? My understanding is that there is currently no dedicated memory service in north Tipperary either, and if that is the case, large parts of the county are effectively without direct access to specialist memory assessment services.

We all know our population is ageing. We know that dementia referrals are increasing year on year. This cannot be dismissed simply as a temporary inconvenience or an administrative issue. This is a systemic failure, in my view.

We talked about ophthalmology a minute ago. We have a similar systems failure with ophthalmology provision in south Tipperary, and we have a similar systematic failure when it comes to orthodontic care in south Tipperary. However, this particular memory clinic service failure is leaving hundreds of patients waiting for a diagnosis and is leaving families in distress.

I plead with the Minister of State to engage directly with the Minister to address the specific issues. When will the review be completed and when will the memory clinic reopen?

I thank Deputy Murphy for raising this very important issue. I am taking this Topical Issue on behalf of the Minister of State with responsibility for older people and housing, Deputy Kieran O'Donnell, who sends his apologies for not being able to be here tonight.

The Deputy is quite right. I was a Minister of State in the previous Dáil for four and a half years, and one of the areas where we made a lot of progress was dementia. Every day in Ireland, there are 30 new cases of dementia. There were 30 yesterday, there are 30 today and there will be another 30 tomorrow. I was delighted to welcome the Minister of State, Deputy O'Donnell, to Cappoquin in Waterford last Friday, where we opened a new dementia day service. It is something I worked on while I was in the role and it was great to get it over the line, because bringing services to people in the community, especially those with dementia, is really important. You can live well with dementia in your community with the correct wraparound supports of home care, day care, meals on wheels and the like of the memory clinics.

When I was asked to take this Topical Issue debate tonight, I was disappointed to hear that one of the 25 memory clinics that I worked so hard to open across the country after Covid had been "paused". I do not like seeing that word at all. Memory clinics are so important. They are a specialist service to support people with memory loss, changes in cognitive formation or dementia. As the Deputy knows, it is located in St. Patrick's Hospital in Cashel in south Tipperary. I appreciate the impact that this is having on people who are awaiting dementia services.

The HSE has advised me that the memory clinic in Cashel has been paused since January this year due to staffing and resourcing issues. I have spoken to the integrated healthcare area manager for south Tipperary this evening. I rang her and she assured me that the HSE was working both locally and nationally to resume the clinic as soon as possible. I am very conscious of the waiting list that the Deputy called out of 450 patients, 168 of whom have had the initial appointment. That is a significant waiting list. Currently, people are referred to the memory clinic either by their general practitioner or through acute hospitals or community specialist teams. Increasing service demand, combined with staffing challenges, has led to longer waiting lists in the memory clinic, as the Deputy alluded to.

The HSE has approved the appointment of a full-time administrative post to support the current clinical administrative systems and allow for their further development. In addition, the current clinic staff are exploring new ways of working to address the waiting lists and resume the provision of a memory clinic service in south Tipperary. As the Deputy quite rightly said, the programme for Government includes a commitment to roll out more memory assessment and support services. I had the honour of being able to write that into the programme for Government. I feel strongly about dementia supports, regardless of where people live. I am disappointed to see that this is the current situation.

I have been told that referrals can be made to the south Tipperary integrated care programme for older persons, ICPOP, team in Thurles, which provides specialist secondary care for people with cognitive decline, falls and frailty. I am conscious that the current situation in south Tipperary is difficult. I will give the Deputy a commitment tonight. I have already spoken to the Minister of State, Deputy O'Donnell's office this evening. We will follow this up rigorously because it is really important. We came from a situation where we did not have many dementia supports. We have 25 memory clinics open. They are vital, the length and breadth of the country. I will work with the Deputy and the Minister of State with responsibility for older people to make sure that we get this up and running again.

I thank the Minister of State for her reply and acknowledge the extent to which she has been a positive force. I acknowledge the Minister of State, Deputy O'Donnell, too, and the establishment of 25 memory clinics around the country. The central issue remains that we have no clear timeline for the restoration of service in south Tipperary. At the heart of my question lie the 450 people awaiting an initial assessment and the 168 awaiting a follow-up appointment. That waiting list will only grow as long as the clinic remains closed. As the Minister of State rightly pointed out, behind every one of those numbers is a person or a family living with uncertainty. Delayed diagnosis can mean delayed treatment, delayed supports and delayed planning for the future. I reference the national dementia model of care, which the Minister of State is familiar with, and the six-week optimal waiting list.

I appreciate the commitment that the Minister of State has given. We really need to push for a timeline for completion of the review and, more importantly, for the restoration of services in Cashel and the re-establishment of the memory clinic in south Tipperary so that we can set a clear plan to address what is a serious and growing waiting list. This is a systematic failure by the HSE. It needs to be corrected and I sincerely welcome the Minister of State's commitment tonight.

I thank the Deputy. Many of the memory clinics evolved organically over many years. I am aware that there is a memory technology resource room in Clonmel, which supports people with technology when, for example, they are living well at home with dementia, but it is important that we get the memory clinic back up and running. These clinics are a vital cog in the wheel. There is an excellent dementia adviser in south Tipperary. I have met her many times. She is fantastic. There is a great partnership with the Alzheimer Society of Ireland. I commend it on the work it does. The opening of the new service in Cappoquin last Friday brought to 62 the number of dementia day services across the country. I commend the Minister of State, Deputy O'Donnell, for following on and making sure that dementia in general remains a key part of the work that he does every day of the week.

We always talk about the prevalence of early onset dementia. We are seeing more and more younger people with it. As the Deputy knows, we had the two fantastic Adams brothers in Ireland only recently. They ran 33 marathons in 33 days. I had the honour of meeting them with the Minister of State, Deputy O'Donnell, and others. We had a very good conversation. I am delighted to say that they will be coming back to Ireland early in July. We will have statements on dementia in the House and the brothers will be present.

I thank the Deputy for putting the spotlight on dementia today, specifically with regard to Cashel and the memory clinic. I will speak with the Minister of State in the next week or so and try to make sure that we get traction and get this service back open as quickly as possible.

Energy Policy

I appreciate the opportunity to raise this extremely important issue. It has been pointed out that last week alone, over €15 million of renewable wind energy was wasted. According to EirGrid, 18% of wind energy was wasted in 2026. For people who do not know, EnergyCloud is delivering free heated water to thousands of people over 120 nights a year and will be helping thousands of homes by the end of 2026. It is demonstrating the link between surplus renewable energy and energy poverty in a very practical way. It is making impacts on a day-to-day basis for people who are in energy poverty. The residents in question have spoken not only of the money, but also of the fact that they now have hot water to wash themselves, their children, their dishes, and their homes. It has a real impact. It removes having to make the choice between heating or eating, and shows what is possible.

Some of the statistics are quite shocking. The programme for Government has a commitment to use surplus renewable energy to help those in fuel energy poverty. Renewable energy wastage came to 2,137 GWh. Approximate retail value of the wasted energy was €756 million. That is an astonishing amount of wasted energy. It is equivalent to 692 million tanks of hot water heated. The average waste per day is €1.633 million. That is energy that is being created every single day that is going to waste.

EnergyCloud is trying to make the connection between the renewable energy that is being created, that cannot be used at a particular time that day, and people who are in energy poverty. When we talk about the cost-of-living crisis that we have at the moment, there are something like 320,000 people currently in energy poverty or energy debt. They are a number of months behind on their payments. The scale of this is absolutely huge. The scale of energy that is being created and wasted is astonishing.

A commitment is required from the Government to support EnergyCloud.

That is what it is asking for. It has sent this email to every single TD. The Minister of State may have received it himself. It is really important that we have that discussion on linking the energy we have here and people in energy poverty. This about enabling them to wash themselves, washing their dishes and heating their homes. It is quite incredible.

I am taking this on behalf of the Minister for Climate, Energy and the Environment, Deputy Darragh O'Brien, who is out of the country. Ireland is fully committed to an ambitious and just green transition, which is essential not only from an environmental perspective, but is also required to reduce our reliance on expensive imported fossil fuels. This involves remaining abreast of new technologies in order to support the integration of increasing volumes of renewables and to further support the use of surplus energy to reduce the amount of wasted energy. Some major challenges exist for electricity systems like ours which are increasingly powered by renewables. These complex issues can only be addressed by taking a systematic approach requiring investment in grid, storage and demand flexibility.

The Department of Climate, Energy and the Environment has engaged widely with relevant stakeholders to identify areas for co-operation in relation to tackling energy poverty and renewable energy waste. A number of key measures are currently under way. First is grid enhancement and interconnection. We are investing €18.9 billion in network infrastructure. The Greenlink interconnector, completed in April 2025, and the forthcoming Celtic interconnector with France will allow us to export surplus energy to European markets during periods of high generation.

Second is the national energy affordability action plan. Through the national energy affordability task force, we are developing an action plan to be published in late 2026. A primary objective is to identify solutions that allow household, particularly those in energy poverty, to avail of low-cost surplus renewable energy.

Third is the electricity storage policy framework. Following the publication of our battery storage framework, we are accelerating the deployment of long-duration storage and batteries. In addition, we are increasing battery capacity to buffer the grid during peak production.

The fourth is the national hydrogen programme. Our new national hydrogen programme task force is overseeing a work programme to develop green hydrogen as a long-term storage solution for surplus wind and solar power.

Fifth is the smart grid and demand response. Through the CRU and ESB Networks, we are expanding "Beat the Peak" initiatives and smart meter incentives, encouraging consumers and large energy users to shift their demand to times of high renewable surplus. The national energy demand strategy aims to make 20% to 30% of electricity demand flexible by 2030. A key aspect of this strategy is preparing households and businesses to maximise their use of renewables.

The sixth is district heating. We are advancing the development of district heating systems to take excess heat from large energy users and other sources to power district heating solutions for both households and businesses.

Finally, the Department of Climate, Energy and the Environment will also lead the development of an integrated strategy on the use of renewable surplus energy, which will co-ordinate technical grid limits, flexible demand, storage deployment and interconnector flows to maximise the use of renewable energy units.

These measures clearly demonstrate our commitment to a just and green transition while managing the current energy affordability strains on households in Ireland.

I welcome the report from the Minister. One of the key things is the national energy affordability task force report which is due to be published late this year. My concern and that of EnergyCloud is that it will come too late for the next budget because it will need investment. Although there is investment in the smart grid and all the things the Minister of State just outlined, I am unsure where it makes the connection between the 550,000 homes where people are living in energy poverty and how that connects with the seven items the Minister of State talked about in his reply.

I welcome the advancements but when one looks at the wasted renewable energy report from EnergyCloud for 16 months until 30 April, as I said, that is €756 million in retail wasted energy. This cannot come too soon for people in energy poverty who, as we speak, are probably not heating their homes. I know we are in June but we are not talking about warm weather today. I welcome the report but there needs to be more urgency about it. People are choosing between heating and eating need it now and they need that support now.

The Department of Climate, Energy and the Environment is acutely aware that, with the scale of renewable electricity generation sources coming onto the grid, the grid needs to be more flexible to account for the intermittent nature of renewables. Moreover, for the decarbonisation pathway to be efficient our energy systems must be smart. A smart and flexible energy system will reduce consumer energy bills by reducing the amount of generation and network assets that need to be built to meet peak demand. Consequently the deployment of energy smart appliances such as electric vehicle charge points, domestic battery storage, energy storage systems, heat pumps and hot water heating solutions is a crucial step for empowering households and businesses to play a central role in Ireland’s energy transition. Some major challenges exist, however, that can only be addressed by taking a systematic approach requiring investment in grid storage and demand flexibility.

The Government remains fully committed to an ambitious and just green transition that is fair and leaves no one behind. The Department of Climate, Energy and the Environment has engaged widely with relevant stakeholders to identify areas for co-operation in relation to tackling energy poverty and renewable energy waste and a number of key measures are currently under way, some of which I referred to in detail earlier.

Post Office Network

We want to raise an issue of deep concern to the community around Griffith Avenue, Glasnevin, in relation to a proposal – which seems to be going ahead – to sell the An Post depot on Griffith Avenue. This has been publicly advertised for sale. Will the Minister of State set out what is planned on this? We have a number of issues of concern to the residents. They really want to stop this happening.

I want to talk about the erosion of a community service. I am conscious the Minister of State may be taking this on behalf a different Minister. I have to be honest - the Minister of State is an Independent who is not part of the same party as the Minister with responsibility for the matter and I am not sure what role the Minister of State at the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine has in relation to the loss of a postal service. I am quite frustrated. Myself and Deputy Hearne are both here at 11.10 p.m. on a Tuesday evening. We equally have families to be home to. I do not think this is an appropriate standard for parliamentary debate. There was no communication with our offices on the change of Ministers. I think it is really disrespectful not only to our role but to the people we represent in our respective constituencies.

I want to speak on the loss of a postal service in Drumcondra but I am also speaking about the erosion of community. Community happens in a multitude of different forms. That postal service parcel delivery office on Home Farm Road, off Griffith Avenue, is a place of congregation. It is a place where older residents in particular in an older part of Dublin city actually find their routine. They find their engagement. They go about their business. It is a source of community. We are about to lose a site from a semi-State entity. There will be a big hole in the ground that once was a State service and residents are angry about it. They are not just angry because of the loss of a particular entity; they are angry because of the loss of a service. There has been no consultation. The residents rightfully feel disrespected.

Further compounding that disrespect, when we strive to have a parliamentary debate about the loss of service, while I respect the Minister of State's role, I have no concept of what happens after this. He will read from a prepared script, but who will take this back to the Minister with responsibility, who seems to be able to give a soundbite to the media about some ridiculousness every once in a while? However, when we are here to engage on a substantive issue, we have nothing. I genuinely feel disrespected and the communities we represent are equally disrespected.

I thank the Deputy for raising this issue. I speak today on behalf of the Minister of State, Deputy McConalogue, who could not be here. I am reading from a prepared script. I welcome the opportunity to outline the position on this matter. An Post is a commercial State company with a mandate to act commercially and as such, day-to-day operational matters including decisions in relation to the size, distribution and future of the network are matters for the board and the management of the company and are not ones in which either the Minister of State or the Minister, Deputy O’Donovan, has a statutory function. The Ministers are aware of the impact that decisions relating to changes in An Post operations have on communities and individuals in both rural and urban areas.

This is a matter for the company. It would be inappropriate for the Government, as a shareholder, to comment on decisions that are for the board and management of An Post to consider. Notwithstanding that this is an operational matter, officials have engaged with the company. An Post has noted it is consolidating its national network of local sorting offices, also known as delivery service units, DSUs. It advises that it needs larger and purpose-fitted premises to manage increased parcel volumes. An Post has advised that as part of a citywide plan over this year and next, it is relocating a number of its delivery offices to new city delivery hubs. Among these will be the An Post delivery offices in Harmonstown, Dublin 5, and Griffith Avenue in Whitehall, Dublin 9, moving to a new north Dublin delivery hub. An Post states that the proposed move is scheduled for the second quarter of next year and there is much to be considered before then. It states that its delivery office in Finglas, Dublin 11, will also be sharing the new facility being completed and purpose-fitted at the North City Business Park in Dublin 11. An Post remains in consultation with staff and unions on the details of these moves.

An Post has further advised that it will facilitate the collection of missed mail locally in local post offices and PostPoint parcel collection pick-up outlets. It states the move will have also little day-to-day impact on local customers as the same postal workers will be delivering to the same local routes as before. An Post advises that it needs much larger premises or repurposed facilities, or both, to manage increased parcel volumes and to meet the future needs of the city and the changing needs of its customers. It notes these new buildings also represent an improvement in working conditions for staff and make huge inroads in terms of sustainability with regard to heating, lighting and the day-to-day operations of buildings like the new delivery hub.

In accordance with section 8.22 of the Code of Practice for the Governance of State Bodies, all State bodies are required to seek the approval of the relevant Minister and the Minister for Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Sector Reform and Digitalisation in advance of any material acquisition or disposal of land, buildings or other material assets proposed by a State body. Departmental officials engage with An Post on various consent requests and An Post is aware of the requirement for compliance with the code of practice. The Government is committed to a sustainable An Post and post office network as a key component of the economic and social infrastructure throughout Ireland. The programme for Government states that the Government will continue to provide the nationwide network of post offices with funding to ensure their sustainability and enhance the value they bring to local communities. The Department of Culture, Communications and Sport is working to deliver on this and an enhanced amount of €15 million per annum has been allocated for supporting the network subject to all legal requirements being satisfied.

In line with the programme for Government, the funding will support the stability and sustainability of the nationwide network of post offices, protecting and nurturing a commercially focused post office network. It will also support access for citizens to the key social benefits of the post office network and help citizens access services effectively.

I again express the deep concern we have for our constituents in Glasnevin and Drumcondra. This service delivery office has been an important local service for the community, and this is happening in the context of the removal of a number of local services like local transport infrastructure, bus changes, the closure of Whitehall Garda station, the loss of parking, restriction on transport and ongoing disruptions. This area also has an older demographic. Residents are deeply concerned that changes being made to essential services like this are being made without any consideration of the combined impact on residents who depend on accessible local infrastructure and services. In particular, it will have a negative impact on the quality of life of older residents, those with mobility challenges and families seeking to remain connected to local services. We are asking if An Post has undertaken an assessment of such accessibility and mobility impacts of the change in services. We are not aware of that. We would like to see these assessments done. We are also asking if ComReg has been addressed about this. On the issue of the material disposal of land, has the Department consented to An Post for the disposal of this according to section 8.22 of the code of practice?

I will speak to the Minister of State in his own capacity. He is an Independent who represents the constituency of Galway West. When he envisioned himself becoming a Minister of State, did he imagine he would be standing in the Chamber defending the closure of local postal services? I appreciate that my constituency and his are very different, but I imagine some of the community needs are the same. The older population in my community of Drumcondra and Glasnevin rely on their post office. When I am told that An Post is a commercial State entity, what does that actually mean? Some State entities do not need to be run for profit. They could also be run for community gain. What we are losing through this erosion of community infrastructure, not only in Dublin Central and Drumcondra, is that community itself. I ask Deputy Grealish to remember why he became an Independent, chose to get involved in politics and became a Minister of State and to stand up for genuine public services such as the post office. I do not for one second doubt he appreciates the need for this type of infrastructure as much as I do. Now that he is sitting in that chair, I ask him to become a custodian of the issue and stand up for this infrastructure. It does not have to be a massive post office. It can be a small postal collection service with other community infrastructure like childcare facilities or anything. Let us show a bit of innovation rather than selling the service off to a private fund, which will be a loss to the community. I would imagine the Minister of State's belief system would go against that.

I thank the Deputy for his comments. When I was on that side of the House, we brought in a lot of Private Members' business about An Post. We always emphasised the importance of the post office and the postman. In all fairness, the postman was the connection with a lot of elderly people living at home. He used to call and check on them to make sure they were there. There is always that fear you will lose the services in the area. I will not read out the script I have in front of me. However, I will get a transcript of what the Deputy said and bring it to the Minister. I will ask him to reply directly to him about the issues he raised.

Schools Building Projects

Táim chun caint anocht faoi Scoil Gharbháin i nDún Garbháin i gContae Phort Láirge. Tá sága - scéal an-fhada - sa scoil seo i dtaobh síneadh a chur leis an bhfoirgneamh scoile. I raise the situation of Scoil Gharbháin in Dungarvan, County Waterford and the long-running saga the school community, the children, teaching staff, management, board and parents have been dealing with over several years.

The Department of education has recently communicated the decision to the school that it is to scale back a long-approved nine-room extension. This decision has caused serious concern in the school community because it cuts across what was previously approved, communicated and planned for and what the school has been working towards in good faith over a number of years. In November 2024, after many years of delay and a lot of miscommunication and shifting goalposts, the Department issued a formal offer for a nine-room extension made up of four mainstream classrooms, two special education classrooms and three special education tuition rooms. That offer was made in response to an already recognised accommodation crisis in the school.

Today, the school has 13 classes but only nine permanent classrooms, meaning the school cannot operate within its own physical capacity. As a result, children are being taught across a fragmented mix of off-site accommodation, prefab buildings and repurposed spaces that were never designed for long-term use. One of the classes is based off-site in a nearby secondary school. That has been the case for three years. This requires daily movement away from the school campus and results in a loss of normal teaching continuity. The children educated off site also lose out on the community they might otherwise enjoy. Another class has been located in the halla for five years. The entirety of the funds to build that halla were raised by the parents and school community. However, for almost all of that five years, it has served as a classroom. That has removed any kind of proper PE and assembly space from the school. The schoolyard is also taken up with two prefabs, which means there is no outdoor paved area for play on those days when it is not lashing rain. Kids are effectively kept in their classrooms. Those in the prefabs are dealing with damp, deteriorating conditions and structural concerns.

The school, which was originally built for 100 pupils, now has 320 and demand is increasing. I should mention that this is a Gaelscoil in Dungarvan. Dungarvan has been recognised as a Gaeltacht service town for a number of years now. Government makes significant investment in promoting the use of Irish as a living community language in the town of Dungarvan. This is the sole Gaelscoil and it is intrinsically important to that project, to the school community, to the children who are educated there and to the promotion of Irish in west Waterford. There is no other Gaelscoil. There is no other option but demand increases. There is a naíonra on site which acts as a feeder for the school. There are waiting lists. Not only is this making teaching very difficult and not only is it impacting the learning experience of the children attending the school but it is also preventing parents from accessing oideachas trí Ghaelainn dá bpáistí, getting an education through the Irish language for their children.

Next to the school is a 155-home housing development that is to come on stream in the next year or year and half. That is much needed in Dungarvan. Demand is only going to increase. In the catchment area, there are two English-language schools but both are landlocked and do not have room to expand. I should also mention that, back when I was a councillor, the Department of education funded Waterford City and County Council to buy a site to build an extension for this school. The site is there. It has been paid for with public funds. Approval was granted but the goalposts are now being shifted. To say that the school community feels utterly dejected and let down would be a massive understatement.

Gabhaim buíochas leis an Teachta. I am taking this on behalf of the Minister for Education and Youth, Deputy Hildegarde Naughton. I will outline to the Dáil the current position on investments in school infrastructure in County Waterford. Waterford county is broken down into five school planning areas. An analysis of the primary school population in Waterford indicates that primary school enrolments will reduce in all areas over the next five years, with the exception of the school planning area of Ring, which may see a small increase in enrolments. Post-primary enrolments in all areas are projected to remain steady and to peak in the next few years.

There are currently four school projects under construction in County Waterford. These projects are in addition to €150 million in capital funding for County Waterford schools since 2020. During that period, over 30 schools in County Waterford were upgraded through the provision of a new school building, a large-scale extension or the provision of modular accommodation. In addition, approximately 120 small-scale improvement works were undertaken across the county's schools to address maintenance needs and enhance energy efficiency. Furthermore, since 2020, a total of 68 special classes have been sanctioned in County Waterford, of which 17 were sanctioned for September 2026.

As the Deputy will be aware, the Department published the €7.55 billion NDP sectoral investment plan for the education and youth sectors for the period from 2026 to 2030 earlier this year. Of the total €7.55 billion investment, it is envisaged that approximately €5 billion will be used for project roll-out to support the delivery and modernisation of school buildings across the large-scale, additional accommodation, modular and annual September accommodation needs programmes.

The Department continues to build on the progress made over recent years with the roll-out of projects on a prioritised basis to meet the most urgent needs in terms of provision of additional capacity and modernisation of existing facilities. In this regard, the Department also published a list of 105 school building projects in the first tranche to proceed to construction or tender over 2026 and 2027. This list included two projects in County Waterford, one of which is the now under construction. The second project has moved to tender stage.

As part of planning ahead for the next tranche of projects to progress to tender, a Department-led prioritisation process will continue over the course of 2026 and 2027. This will include engagement with key stakeholders, including meetings with patrons this month. The Department-led energy and condition survey of the school estate, which will be finalised later in 2026, will provide an additional evidence base for assessing priorities. A next tranche of projects to proceed to tender is expected to be announced in 2027.

Investment under the plan also involves the delivery of the first tranche of 297 projects under the climate action summer works scheme. This includes seven projects in County Waterford that are approved to undergo works this summer.

Gabhaim buíochas as sin ach níl sé ró-úsáideach dom ná do na daoine atá bainteach leis an scoil seo. I thank the Minister of State for the response. I appreciate him being here to read it. However, similar to other speakers tonight, I will put on record that I would much prefer it if one of the two Ministers in the Department of education were here. Neither is. That in itself tells us something. We could have a more engaging and robust conversation. That is no criticism of the Minister of State. To be fair, he is here doing his job.

What we need here is real and meaningful engagement with the school. I had the school principal, the deputy principal and the chairperson of the board of management in Leinster House for some meetings this evening. I understand they are going to meet with the Minister tomorrow. However, that cannot just be a meeting to go through what the Minister of State has just said here. I hope the Minister has more to say to the school because this is holding back the ability of children to get an education, of educators to do their jobs safely and of parents to vindicate their children's right to an education through the medium of Irish.

No matter what way you cut it, this is an infringement of children's basic rights, such as the right of children with special educational needs attending this excellent school to be able to get the educational interventions they need and deserve in an adequate and appropriate place. It infringes the right of children who are learning to move around during their break times and not be stuck in a classroom, sometimes a prefab classroom, without access to a halla or clós to go outside and play. We need a can-do attitude from the Minister tomorrow. We do not need a litany of what has been achieved, what might be achieved and what is aspired to. It is about the nuts and bolts of remedying this situation. If it is a matter of pointing to a miscommunication or error on the Department's part that it is going to solve, that is fine. We will take that all day long but we need an approach that aims to fix this and sets out how, and that involves working with the school community. They are reasonable people but they have been trying to get this extension for years.

The Department has a strong track record of delivering the Government's school building programme, with over €6.9 billion invested since 2020. This has delivered more than 1,400 completed school building projects along with over 4,000 small-scale improvement works to meet priority maintenance needs and advance energy efficiency and climate goals. A total capital ceiling of €7.55 billion for 2026 to 2030 was allocated to the Department of Education and Youth under the national development plan review. This is a record level of investment in school buildings. It will expand the number of school places, significantly increase provision for special education, and upgrade and modernise our school infrastructure. The impact of this will be felt in communities right around the country. This €7.55 billion investment will be prioritised to ensure every child has a school place and it will support the overall operation of the school system and youth sector in terms of capital infrastructure. The Department puts a very strong emphasis on achieving value for money. Its focus is on delivering good quality functional accommodation for schools based on its suite of standard designs and specifications.

That is the response I was given from officials in the Department of education. I wish the Deputy well in the meeting tomorrow. It is important that the school engages with the Minister. Perhaps, they will get some good news.

Cuireadh an Dáil ar athló ar 11.31 p.m. go dtí 9 a.m., Dé Céadaoin, an 10 Meitheamh 2026.
The Dáil adjourned at 11.31 p.m. until 9 a.m. on Wednesday, 10 June 2026.
Roinn